In a significant development in the long-standing legal battle over the “Please Call Me” idea, the Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa has dismissed Vodacom’s appeal. The telecommunications giant expressed surprise and disappointment with the judgment, announcing its intention to bring the matter before the Constitutional Court of South Africa.
Background
The Please Call Me matter traces back to a 2016 Constitutional Court order, which mandated Vodacom’s CEO to determine reasonable compensation for Kenneth Nkosana Makate, the originator of the concept. Initially, Vodacom offered Makate R47 million, which he rejected, prompting him to seek judicial intervention.
Legal Proceedings
Following Makate’s rejection, the matter landed in the Gauteng Division of the High Court of South Africa. On February 8, 2022, the High Court set aside the CEO’s determination, instructing Vodacom to reconsider the settlement offered to Makate. Vodacom promptly filed an application for leave to appeal against the High Court’s decision on February 25, 2022.
However, on February 6, 2024, the Supreme Court handed down its judgment, dismissing Vodacom’s appeal and leaving the telecommunications company to explore further legal avenues.
Next Steps
Vodacom, not deterred by the recent setback, has announced its intention to seek leave to appeal before the Constitutional Court of South Africa within the prescribed period. This move indicates the company’s commitment to pursue all available legal options in the Please Call Me matter.
Reaction and Implications
The dismissal of Vodacom’s appeal by the Supreme Court marks a significant turn in this protracted legal battle. While Vodacom’s determination of R47 million as compensation for Makate was already considered generous by some, Makate’s insistence on further review has led to ongoing legal strife.
The implications of this decision extend beyond the legal realm. The Please Call Me concept has been a point of contention for over a decade, highlighting the complexities surrounding intellectual property rights and fair compensation in the telecommunications industry.
Conclusion
As Vodacom prepares to take its case to the Constitutional Court, the Please Call Me matter remains a focal point of public interest and debate. The outcome of this legal saga will not only impact the involved parties but may also set precedents for future disputes over intellectual property rights in South Africa’s evolving digital landscape.
This website uses cookies.
