Harvard’s Solutions Offer Hope for South Africa’s Recovery

  • State Capacity Crisis: South Africa faces a severe decline in state capacity affecting various sectors, particularly the energy industry. The collapse of reliable electricity generation from coal resources has hampered growth, attributing to a significant reduction in the country's competitiveness and growth potential.
  • Challenges and Causes: The collapse is attributed to political gridlock, exclusionary ideologies, overburdening public entities, and rampant political patronage. Municipal governments, burdened with responsibilities without adequate resources, face significant challenges due to premature decentralization and procurement constraints.
  • Harvard's Proposed Solutions: The Growth Lab at Harvard University offers comprehensive solutions, emphasizing the need to restore the country's electricity advantage, revamp municipal governance, and bolster overall state capacity. Recommendations include establishing a functional electricity market, redistributing responsibilities in municipalities, easing procurement constraints, and reforming the civil service to address the root causes of state collapse.

As South Africa grapples with severe challenges to its state capacity, the Growth Lab at Harvard University has unveiled a series of comprehensive solutions targeting the nation’s critical issues, particularly the energy crisis. These measures aim to reinvigorate the country’s growth while specifically tailoring solutions for South Africa’s socio-economic landscape.

Harvard’s insights emphasize two pivotal hurdles obstructing inclusive growth in the nation: dwindling state capacity and spatial exclusion. The erosion of South Africa’s administrative strength has cast a shadow across multiple sectors, including electricity, transportation, ports, and water supply, exerting profound effects on the operations of local governments.

One of the major setbacks has been the decline in the country’s advantage in producing cost-effective and dependable electricity from coal resources. This decline, which formerly bolstered South Africa’s competitiveness in energy-intensive industries like mineral processing, has critically hampered the nation’s growth trajectory.

The repercussions of an unreliable energy supply have been dire, with estimations from the South African Reserve Bank indicating that the electricity crisis alone is shaving off two percentage points from the nation’s growth rate.

The researchers highlighted four primary causes contributing to this systemic collapse:

  1. Political gridlock hindering effective action within the ruling coalition.
  2. An exclusionary ideology limiting society’s participation in state-regulated activities.
  3. Overloading public entities with objectives beyond their core competencies.
  4. Rampant political patronage corrupting both the state and the ruling coalition.

To address these deep-rooted challenges, the report emphasizes the necessity of rectifying the fundamental causes that have precipitated the state’s collapse. Mere cessation of power outages is deemed insufficient; rather, South Africa must reinstate its erstwhile advantage in providing low-cost and dependable electricity.

The report identifies governmental restrictions impeding private sector participation in electricity provision and emphasizes the urgency of establishing a well-structured electricity market. Moreover, it calls attention to the dearth of investments in transmission and storage capacities, restricting power generation.

Municipal governments, burdened with numerous responsibilities without adequate local capacities, face substantial challenges. The decentralization strategy two decades ago saddled municipalities with excessive duties without commensurate support or resources, especially in essential services like electricity and water distribution.

The researchers advocate for the reevaluation of preferential procurement systems that, while aiming for socio-economic transformation, paradoxically exclude the very communities they intend to empower. Addressing these constraints could yield substantial cost savings amounting to a significant percentage of South Africa’s GDP.

In light of these challenges, the Growth Lab offers a set of targeted recommendations:

Addressing the Energy Crisis:

  1. Create a robust electricity market allowing greater societal participation in generation, transmission, distribution, and storage.
  2. Appoint a reform-oriented individual to facilitate implementation and unbundling of the sector.
  3. Eliminate preferential procurement requirements for Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement (REIPPP) projects.
  4. Focus REIPPP programs on transmission and storage investments.

Strengthening Municipal Governments:

  1. Redistribute responsibility for electricity and water distribution to efficient regulated monopolies.
  2. Establish national/regional service providers to support municipalities lacking local expertise.

Enhancing State Capacity:

1.Ease preferential procurement requirements on State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) and other public entities.

2.Gradually reform the civil service to minimize reliance on political deployments.

3.Facilitate societal contributions to fill supply gaps in network industries through clear market mechanisms.

These targeted solutions, if implemented effectively, offer a pathway for South Africa to rejuvenate its state capacity and address the multifaceted challenges hampering its growth trajectory. The successful revival of administrative strength, coupled with strategic reforms, holds the promise of a brighter economic future for the nation.

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Stay ahead in the financial world – Sign Up to Rateweb’s essential newsletter for free. Get the latest insights on business trends, tech innovations, and market movements, directly to your inbox. Join our community of savvy readers and never miss an update that could impact your financial decisions.

Do you have a news tip for Rateweb reporters? Please email us at


Start trading with a free $30 bonus

Trade stocks, forex, commodities, metals and CFDs on stock indices with an internationally licensed and regulated broker. For all clients who open their first real account, XM offers a $30 trading bonus without any initial deposit needed. Learn more about how you can trade over 1000 instruments on the XM MT4 and MT5 platforms from your PC and Mac, or from a variety of mobile devices.


Personal Financial Tools

Below is a list of tools built to assist South Africans to make the best financial decisions:



South Africa’s primary source of financial tools and information

Contact Us



Rateweb strives to keep its information accurate and up to date. This information may be different than what you see when you visit a financial institution, service provider or specific product’s site. All financial products, shopping products and services are presented without warranty. When evaluating offers, please review the financial institution’s Terms and Conditions.

Rateweb is not a financial service provider and should in no way be seen as one. In compiling the articles for our website due caution was exercised in an attempt to gather information from reliable and accurate sources. The articles are of a general nature and do not purport to offer specialised and or personalised financial or investment advice. Neither the author, nor the publisher, will accept any responsibility for losses, omissions, errors, fortunes or misfortunes that may be suffered by any person that acts or refrains from acting as a result of these articles.